Lucky Star Sig/Banner

[Kokingz]

well well here i go again... i intended to make a Kogami Akira Sig but i had noone to make it for and stuff so it turned out to be more of a banner.... annyways i welcome critics and comments.... ^^

Big


Small

[MangaFever]

well well here i go again... i intended to make a Kogami Akira Sig but i had noone to make it for and stuff so it turned out to be more of a banner.... annyways i welcome critics and comments.... ^^

Big


Small

They are very cute ..Good job

[Mo7ammed]

it's a good think you made a smaller version because the text in the bigger one looked slightly pixelated
1- i see no border
2- the ani-haven star thing isn't shown completely, the top of the star is cut out.. i'm not sure if it's on purpose, i don't like it not being completely shown.
3- the 2 renders looked so random to me... took me time to know your idea.. which is having the render on left bored-looking on the clutzy one on right... the star between them kinda distract it..
4- it would've been better if you wrote the ani haven site link somewhere on a corner instead of having it inside a star and even taking 3 lines..

enough criticizing.. any more might be overdoing it   


i'ts a good thing that now you know how to make animated  sigs coz it's a bit difficult to do for some people, and a lot difficutl to make something good out of it.. even most of my animated ones look silly 

[Daniel]

it's not really anything complex, but i like it  simple, but nice. though, i'd pay a little more attention to detail next time, despite how simple it is (note some of what momu said & also increase quality of overall image, very not HD, if you know what i mean ha)

[Kokingz]

it's a good think you made a smaller version because the text in the bigger one looked slightly pixelated
1- i see no border
2- the ani-haven star thing isn't shown completely, the top of the star is cut out.. i'm not sure if it's on purpose, i don't like it not being completely shown.
3- the 2 renders looked so random to me... took me time to know your idea.. which is having the render on left bored-looking on the clutzy one on right... the star between them kinda distract it..
4- it would've been better if you wrote the ani haven site link somewhere on a corner instead of having it inside a star and even taking 3 lines..

enough criticizing.. any more might be overdoing it  


i'ts a good thing that now you know how to make animated  sigs coz it's a bit difficult to do for some people, and a lot difficutl to make something good out of it.. even most of my animated ones look silly  

well i took everything for this out of the actuall series.... so background just is like that on the show... dunno if u have watched lucky star.... but i just replaced "lucky Channel" with "Ani-Haven.net" @ Daniel the frames are fetched from the MKV.... dunno where to get better quality... and i dont really see anny need for it.... i even managed to keep it small enough so the gif compression went well without messing with the qualy...and its the most complex banner i did so far...

well like i said its more of a banner not actually a sig hence there is no real topic... well if u actually watched the show u may think its funny if not....... watch it!!!

annyways ur critics are as allways understandable and welcome momo.... though i hoped to get some positiv answeres too =__=

[Mo7ammed]

poor kokingz...
i only give you harsh criticizing because i was given the same harsh comments whe.... err i mean i am harsh because i love you kokingz >.>

i know that you tried real hard doing it, i'm quite sure of it coz i can tell, but the problem is people don't assess by how hard you work, they asses on how good looking the thing in front of them is... sadly it is a fact...

it happened to me a lot as well

[Kokingz]

okay here my sources  

[Daniel]

yep yepp. the result is what counts..

and although it may be the most complex to make, it's visuallly not that complex. that is what i meant